Hydra vs Poros: Which Greek Island is Right for You?

This summer, I found myself facing a tough (but beautiful) dilemma: choosing between the Greek islands of Hydra and Poros as my home base. 

Both had been on my radar for their charm, ease of access from Athens, and relaxed island vibes, but I had to pick just one. 

After doing the research, weighing the pros and cons, and finally experiencing both, I want to share everything I learned to help you decide which island is the right fit for your trip. 

In this post, you can expect a breakdown of the most commonly contemplated factors. I’m talking about things like cost, things to do, proximity to the beach, transportation, and overall vibe.

Quick Comparison: Hydra and Poros

Category	Hydra	Poros

Close to Athens

Yes (approx. 2 hours)

Yes (approx. 1 hour)

Ferry Ticket Cost

€36–€38 one way (high-speed)

€18–€36 one way (high-speed)

Ferry Duration

1–2 hours

~1 hour

Average Hotel Cost

€100–€180 per night

€60–€120 per night

Average Food Cost

€20–€35 per day (mid-range)

€15–€25 per day (mid-range)

Rather a day trip from Athens to 3 islands? Check out the Boat Tour to Hydra, Poros, and Aegina Day Cruise with Lunch.

Hydra vs. Poros: Which Island Is Easier to Reach?

Both of these Saronic islands are conveniently accessible from Athens by ferry, making them perfect options for a day trip. They are on the same ferry route, with Poros being the first stop and Hydra about 30 minutes further on most high-speed ferries.

Because of this, the difference in travel time between the two is minimal and not really something that should influence your decision.

This is very different from comparing islands like Naxos and Rhodes, which belong to completely different island groups and are much harder to combine in one trip. When it comes to ease of getting there, Hydra and Poros are essentially equal.

You Also Might Like: Complete Guide to the Greek Islands

Vibe and Atmosphere: Comparing Hydra and Poros

The vibe on Hydra and Poros is quite different. Or at least, that was my impression after spending four nights between the two islands. It is hard to say which one is more beautiful because they each offer something unique.

Hydra is much smaller. Not just in overall island size, but also in terms of the areas where you will likely stay and explore. You can easily explore all of Hydra in one day.

Poros, by comparison, feels more spread out and has more to offer in terms of occupied space and local life.

The atmosphere is also noticeably different. Hydra has a more polished and upscale feel. It has a reputation for attracting yachts, boutique hotels, and a more resort-like crowd.

There is even a Four Seasons on the island, which tells you a lot about the kind of experience it caters to.

Poros felt much more casual to me. It is not as upmarket, and I actually liked that. It came across as more authentic and down-to-earth.

While both islands are beautiful, they offer very different experiences in terms of vibe and energy.

Accessible Beaches on Hydra and Poros

Let’s talk about the beaches on Hydra and Poros. For the sake of simplicity, I am going to assume you are planning a short trip and staying in or near the main town on each island.

If your whole vacation revolves around beach time, I can definitely suggest some additional spots. But first, here is a look at the closest and most accessible beaches from the Chora port areas on both islands.

Hydra

---

Hydra Beaches (close to the port):

There are two main swimming areas within walking distance of the port. One of them is not technically a beach, but it is a great swimming spot right off the restaurant and bar called Spilia.

You can lay a towel down on the cement platform below and enjoy the view without having to order anything. However, if you want to sit at a table or use one of their chairs, you will need to be a customer.

I actually had a surprisingly great meal here. The fish tacos were fantastic, and the views were absolutely next level.

The second spot is a small beach just a little further down from Spilia called Avlaki Beach. There is a staircase that leads down to it, although technically it is blocked off.

That said, everyone just scoots around the barrier and heads down anyway.

‼️ If stairs are a challenge for you, then neither of these Hydra town options will be ideal.

Hydra Beaches (away from the port):

If you are looking for a more traditional beach experience, you can take a short boat ride from the port to Mandrakia Resort.

It costs about 10 euros for a round trip and only takes around ten minutes to get there. The beach is part of a hotel property, so you will need to pay for the beach chairs. As you might expect, they are not cheap.

I still think the experience is worth recommending, especially if you want to spend a relaxing afternoon by the sea.

Just know in advance that the food is not particularly memorable, and the portions are on the small side and the drinks are wildly overpriced. I have a photo of the spot below so you can see what to expect.

Poros 

---

Poros Beaches (close to the port):

There are two beaches within about a 15-minute walk from the old town of Poros. One of them, Paralia Agiou Stefanou, is technically closer, but I would not recommend it.

It is located right next to a military facility, and the atmosphere is just not what you imagine when you think of a relaxing Greek island beach. It might be convenient, but it is definitely not the vibe.

A better option is Paralia Kanali. It is a little further, but still an easy and flat walk from the port. This beach has sunbeds for rent, a gentle shoreline, and a more welcoming atmosphere overall.

If you are looking for a convenient spot to enjoy the sun and sea without venturing too far, it will absolutely do the job. It is clean, relaxed, and easy to access.

Poros (away from the port):

If you are in search of that classic Greek island beach bliss, I would suggest heading to Anasa Beach.

This one is highly recommended and very easy to reach by taking a taxi (6 min ride). It is a great choice if you want to spend a full day by the sea in a more scenic and peaceful setting, with better swimming and a more curated beach experience.

Things to Do in Hydra and Poros

When it comes to sightseeing, both Hydra and Poros offer a more low-key experience compared to the larger Greek islands.

You won’t find ancient ruins around every corner, but there are a few cultural and historical spots worth visiting, especially if you enjoy museums, coastal walks, and learning about local history.

Hydra Highlights:

• Historical Archives Museum of Hydra
  Located right by the port, this museum offers a glimpse into Hydra’s important role during the Greek War of Independence. It features maritime artifacts, historic documents, and 19th-century portraits.
• Lazaros Kountouriotis Mansion
  This beautiful neoclassical home, once belonging to one of Hydra’s most influential families, has been turned into a museum. It offers traditional furnishings, art, and a panoramic view over the harbor.
• Walking the Coastal Path
  While not an official attraction, walking along Hydra’s coastal path west from the port is one of the best free activities. It leads past cafes, swimming spots, and ends at the village of Kamini.
• No Cars on the Island
  The fact that Hydra is entirely car-free makes wandering around the narrow streets feel like stepping back in time. What is the local mode of transport when you need to go from one side of the island to the other? Donkey!

Organized Tours to Consider in Hydra:

• Hydra Island Boat Tour with Lunch

Poros Highlights:

• Archaeological Museum of Poros
  Located in the main square, this small museum houses finds from the nearby Sanctuary of Poseidon, which was an important religious site in antiquity.
• Sanctuary of Poseidon (Mythology Alert!)
  Poros has a deeper connection to Greek mythology than Hydra. The Sanctuary of Poseidon, now in ruins, was once a major religious site dedicated to the god of the sea. It also served as a refuge for those seeking asylum in ancient times. Don’t confuse this place with the Temple of Poseidon, which is more interesting in my opinon.
• Poros Clock Tower
  Perched above the town, the iconic clock tower is a great spot for sunset and panoramic views of the island and surrounding sea.
• Stroll Around the Neorio Bay Area
  A scenic part of the island with a mix of nature and classic Greek coastal charm. It’s great for a relaxed walk, a swim, or grabbing a coffee by the water.

Which Island Has Better Food: Hydra or Poros?

There is no question in my mind that Hydra has the better restaurants. In fact, it is listed as one of the best Greek islands for foodies.

That said, both islands can be counted on for fresh, traditional Greek food. You will always find a great Greek salad or grilled fish.

But if you are looking for restaurants that go the extra mile in creativity and presentation, Hydra stands out.

Hydra Recommendations

Techne
This spot offers Mediterranean cuisine with bold flavors and beautifully presented dishes. If they are still serving the crab pasta, as pictured below, it is a must-try. I also recommend starting with the taramosalata dip. And make a reservation, you don’t want to miss out!

Omilos
I am not sure why Omilos does not have ratings as high as Techne, because the food is fantastic. I always go for the fresh fish, but there are great options for non-seafood lovers too. The location and views add even more to the experience.

Which Island Is More Expensive to Visit?

If you are only doing a day trip, then technically Hydra may be slightly more expensive due to the higher ferry ticket price. But once you arrive, the cost difference depends on your choices.

Hydra definitely leans more upscale when it comes to hotels, shops, and restaurants. However, that does not mean you cannot visit Hydra on a budget. 

The key is to avoid the restaurants right at the port. If you wander a little into the neighborhoods, you will find more affordable dining options and in my experience, better food.

Poros is more budget-friendly overall. Accommodations, dining, and activities tend to cost less, making it a great choice if you want to stretch your travel budget.

The average cost on both islands you should expect to pay for a Greek salad is from 9 to 11 euros. Aperol Spritz for around 9 – 12 euros. Hotels vary greatly, more below.

Poros or Hydra Accommodations: Which Island Is Better to Stay On?

I saved this section for last because choosing where to stay really depends on what you are looking for in your trip. Your decision should reflect the overall vibe that best fits your travel style.

As I mentioned earlier, Poros is the more affordable option. But that does not mean you cannot find a good deal on Hydra as well.

If you are craving boutique charm, Hydra delivers. There are more high-end and stylish places to stay, many with beautiful architecture and thoughtful details.

One of my favorites is the Leto Hotel, a five-star stay with elegant decor and lovely touches like traditional Greek candies on the pillow. I found it charming and welcoming.

On my most recent trip, I also toured several properties that I really loved. You will find those listed below.

• Greco Hotel (Budget friendly)
• Piteoussa Guesthouse (budget friendly)
• Angelica VIP Boutique Hotel
• Cotommatae Hydra 1810

Things You Might Not Think About When Picking a Place to Stay

The streets on Greek islands are super cute, but not what I would call luggage-friendly. Think uneven stones, stairs, hills, and tiny paths.

That adorable little hotel with the dream view? It might be up a steep walkway or a bunch of stairs, and no taxi is getting anywhere near it.

Some hotels will offer help getting from the port, but most of the small guesthouses won’t. So before you book, it’s a good idea to ask what the walk is like from the port to the hotel. Is it uphill? Are there a ton of stairs? Is it a five-minute stroll or a sweaty climb?

Just something to think about, especially if you are arriving with a suitcase or coming in when it’s hot. It can make a big difference in how your trip starts.

Choosing What Feels Right for You

Honestly, I do not think you can go wrong with either island. Both Hydra and Poros are beautiful, easy to reach, and offer a slower, more peaceful Greek island vibe compared to the more tourist-heavy spots.

What it really comes down to is your travel style. If you are into boutique hotels, a little luxury, and a more polished feel, then Hydra might be your perfect match. If you are more budget-minded, want something a little more laid-back and authentic, Poros could be the better fit.

Think about how you want to spend your time. Do you care more about the food scene or the beach access? Are you packing light or hauling a rolling suitcase over cobblestones? Are you looking for a romantic escape, a solo recharge, or a relaxed trip with friends?

Whatever you decide, both islands are well worth the visit. I hope this helped make your decision a little easier and gave you some insight into what to expect. If you have questions or want to know more about the hotels I visited, feel free to reach out or check the list below

Where Would I Stay Again?
Me personally, I’m a hydra girl, but that doesn’t mean you won’t love staying on Poros. The best part about the Saronic islands is that you can easily visit them on day trips because they are so close together! 

Have more specific questions, let me know!